Dealing with Challenges in On-site Concrete Slump Tests: A Practical Guide for Engineers

Imagine the scene: your client is staring at a slump cone test gone wrong, and you, as an engineer, need to make the right call. What do you do when faced with a failed on-site slump test? This article explores the decisions engineers can make and the measures they can take to address the situation.

Understanding Slump Values

Concrete consistency is key, and the slump test measures it from batch to batch. The slump value, ranging from 25 mm to 75 mm for vibrated concrete, is crucial for workability.

Failed Slump Test: Troubleshooting Strategies

Low Slump Value: If the slump is low, water or superplasticizer can be added following guidelines in Table-1. Care must be taken not to exceed the maximum water-cement ratio.

High Slump Value: Dealing with a high slump value is trickier. Repeating the test or allowing the mixer to revolve for 10 minutes may help. If the slump remains high, adding cement to the mix is an option.

Slump Failure Criteria

If the slump value doesn’t fall within the specified range, a check test on another sample is necessary. Two consecutive failures indicate a lack of cohesiveness and plasticity, as per ASTM C94.

Engineer’s Decision After a Failed Slump Test

The engineer faces a dilemma. Rejecting the concrete and suspending work is an option, emphasizing the importance of meeting designated strength. However, a slump test alone doesn’t necessarily dictate concrete strength reduction.

Allowing the concreting process to continue requires adjustments. The contractor must prove compliance with other contractual requirements, such as compression tests.

Balancing Workability, Strength, and Durability

Workability is tied to both strength and durability. Even if the concrete attains the designated strength, durability may still be compromised.

Conclusion: Ensuring Quality Concrete

In conclusion, failed slump tests demand thoughtful decisions. Engineers must navigate the balance between workability, strength, and durability. Proper adjustments, adherence to guidelines, and, if necessary, additional testing can salvage a situation where the initial slump test fails. The goal is to ensure quality concrete that meets project requirements.

Leave a comment